Is England backing the wrong approach to new woodland?
This article was originally shared by Jan on LinkedIn. We'd love to hear your thoughts. Join the conversation in the comments.

I wrote something a bit controversial (for me) in Heal’s latest newsletter. Cue a flood of emails – the most we’ve ever had in 78 editions. What was so spicy? Tree planting. Everyone loves new trees, but seeing crispy dead saplings after two years of drought is clearly triggering.
TL;DR should tree planting keep getting nearly all the money for new woodland (reportedly 95% since 2021), when natural regeneration may be as effective and cost less?
As far as I could find out, £816 million has been allocated to tree planting in England up to 2029, and a report suggests only about 5% of woodland creation funding since 2021 has gone to natural regeneration. Does this balance of investment still make sense?
Many of the naturally regenerating trees at our Heal Somerset rewilding site (which have appeared since 2023) have come through this summer's drought. For example, volunteers counted 271 living baby oak trees in about two thirds of an acre in mid-September, with only a handful of dead ones that they could find. Why such a good survival rate? Such saplings may be more resilient from the start, with a root system which has been established in situ and possibly with mycorrhizal fungi from nearby adult trees. However, we also need to see what happens to those young trees after repeated droughts and other impacts.
Meanwhile, I heard an anecdote last week from one of our volunteers who helps at a site which had done large-scale tree planting, with watering being impractical (the case in many such settings). A huge proportion (perhaps two-thirds, they thought) of saplings were dead after this summer's drought.
I know anecdotes aren't proof. I also know there will always be a need to plant trees and that natural regeneration doesn't suit every site. But natural regeneration generally costs less and many tree-planting expenses like stock and labour are incurred again whenever dead saplings have to be replaced.
I have a lot of love for all those groups doing tree planting but at the same time, we need to be honest about the impact on saplings and whether all of us should be considering natural regeneration as a mainstream parallel track.
In that vein, surely now is the moment to review the balance of investment between tree planting and natural regeneration. Fundholders should be looking at the evidence following these two record-breaking summers. I would wager that evidence will show that natural regeneration deserves a much bigger share. This can be spent supporting nature recovery projects at scale, like Heal Somerset.
As people, we love to feel active, to feel that we’re making a difference, but sometimes letting nature do its thing is the best approach. Trust nature, I would say. It has had 3.5 billion years’ practice.











Comments